| F. Bowers | “Hamlet as Minister and Scourge” |
| 1968 | Hamlet as Minister and Scourge date |
| Hamlet as Minister and Scourge | based on response to killing Polonius, explains Hamlet’s complexities. Hamlet delays action in favor of God’s Providence. |
| minister | righteous agent used against evil |
| scourge | damned human used for revenge |
| A.C. Bradley | “Hamlet” (Shakespearean Tragedy) |
| 1904 | date AC Bradley’s Hamlet written |
| 1964 | date AC Bradley’s Hamlet written (2) |
| “Hamlet” | focuses on character of Hamlet, his passivity based on melancholy; melancholy explains Hamlet’s action; studies Ophelia/Gertrude/Claudius/Ghost; Acknowledges many facts of Hamlet are untouched. |
| M. Doran | “Excerpt from Shakespeare’s Dramatic Language” |
| 1986 | Excerpt from Shakespeare’s Dramatic Language date |
| “Excerpt from Shakespeare’s Dramatic Language” | Hamlet is voice of truth in world of lies; his speech is more realistic than players and Claudius; Hamlet’s speech is more controlled than Laertes’. 4 styles of Hamlet’s voices: language of passion, language of mockery, language of reflection, everyday conversation. Hamlet is most complete and human character in the play. |
| T.S. Eliot | “Hamlet and His Problems” |
| 1991 | “Hamlet and His Problems” date |
| “Hamlet and His Problems” | Hamlet is an artistic failure, few evaluate Hamlet as a play, Eliot hates superfluous scenes, variable maturity with mishandled motives, Hamlet has too many emotions (in excess of facts), no “objective correlative” to express emotions. |
| GK Hunter | “The Heroism of Hamlet” |
| 1963 | The Heroism of Hamlet date |
| “The Heroism of Hamlet” | Crucial midpoint of Shakespeare’s study of “nature of heroism”, evolves from superhuman king to general; hamlet sees qualities of heroism in peers and assimilates them into his personality; Fortinbras’ action/Laertes’ passion/Horatio’s “Christian-Stoicism”; Hamlet can’t just compile or imitate heroic ideas; Hamlet goes mad to handle paradox: coherence in experience and capacity to generalize; Hamlet faces “slings and arrows” and maintains control. |
| E. Jones | “Hamlet and Oedipus” |
| 1949 | Hamlet and Oedipus date |
| “Hamlet and Oedipus” | psychoanalytic approach finds repressed attraction for Gertrude; mix of guilt over father’s death, repulsion over mom’s behavior, revenge for Claudius’ usurpation; repressed desire to kill dad resurfaces to kill Claudius; Neurosis explains Hamlet’s character and inability to have relationship with Ophelia; doesn’t explain why Hamlet speaks well of dad he wants to kill. |
| H. Levin | “Chapter 2: Doubt” |
| 1959 | Chapter 2: Doubt date |
| “Chapter 2: Doubt” | Structures around study of 3 tropes: interrgatio (interrogation), dubitatio (doubt), ironia (irony); “Duality” – exists because hamlet’s state of mind is doubt; questioner faces no single answer nor lack of one; double entendre/double talk/dual roles/dual responsibilities/double dealing/what is and what was/being or not being; doubt leads to hesitation; hamlet is state of perplexity. |
| M. Maynard | “The World of Hamlet” |
| 1968 | “The World of Hamlet” date |
| “The World of Hamlet” | Hamlet can’t be understood outside of his world; dominant attributes of Hamlet’s world; mysteriousness/recurrent discrepancy between reality and appearance/sense of morality; mystery in opening scene. Hamlet’s problem is that of the avenger, act V: hamlet comes to terms with responsibility and context. |
| JD Wilson | “Hamlet’s Make-Up” |
| 1936 | “Hamlet’s Make-Up” date |
| “Hamlet’s Make-Up” | Rejects interpretations of Hamlet that depend on terms or ideas; must be studied in terms of Elizabethan dramatic context; focuses on plot, argues Hamlet is not glaring procrastinator until after the Mousetrap; mental hysterics: supreme illusion of great and mysterious character; hero is complex and contradictory and human. |
| WH Auden | “Hamlet” (Lectures on Shakespeare) |
| 2000 | “Hamlet” (Lectures on Shakespeare) date |
| Hamlet (Lectures on Shakespeare) | Hamlet has lots of faults: Polonius’ burial/Fortinbras’ portrayal/lack of motivation/Hamlet’s age/love for Ophelia; points out subplot issues; is hamlet just big and bored and spoiled and rich? |
Hamlet Critics
October 23, 2019
Previous Post
